
Every post-mortem I have sat through has the same line in it. “The strategy was right, but execution let us down.”
I have been pushing back on this for years. In 2013 I wrote Execution Rules, Strategy Drools, and my view hasn’t changed. There is no such thing as an awesome strategy with awful execution. If the people and money you actually had couldn’t pull it off, it wasn’t awesome. It was a nice idea. Strategy and execution are different only because one comes first. Once the work starts they should be the same thing, with what you learn from executing changing the strategy. There is a reason the top job is Chief Executive Officer.
In 2020 I wrote What the heck is strategy? and added a piece I had underplayed. When we don’t acknowledge the real constraints, we end up saying ridiculous things like “great strategy, but execution failed us.” Acknowledge them up front, then challenge them from first principles to see if they are as real as they look.
A poor say/do ratio has the same root. Organizations talk about it as if people are flaky. Mostly we just say far more than we can handle. Saying is cheap and gets applause today. The bill arrives two quarters later, usually when someone else is holding it. Nobody takes anything off the list when they add to it, and every yes looks small on its own. I wrote in 2020 that it is easy to pile on assumptions and get overconfident. Each assumption nobody checks turns into a promise nobody can keep.
This is where zooming in and out comes in. Most of these failures come from sitting at one altitude. The leader who says the strategy was right has never followed one customer problem from the board slide down to the person who has to fix it. The leader with the long list has never added up the work on the ground and held it against the size of the team.
You teach this by making people do it. Have them trace one real thread, top to bottom. Put strategy people in a customer queue for a few weeks, and put detail people in front of the board. When something doesn’t add up, say out loud that you are going down to look. People copy that.
It is also exhausting, as I said in 2020. That is a good reason to grow more leaders who can do it, so you can save your own energy for fewer, bigger decisions. Give them a compass and not a map, and leave room to improvise.
If I had to boil it down to two questions: what are we stopping to make room for this? And if the strategy is right, what should I be seeing on the ground? If I can’t answer the second one, I should go and look.