Today marks my one month anniversary at MongoDB – time just flew by , and I am having a great time . If there is one frustration with my new gig – it is the term “NoSQL”. This term provides nothing but grief . Does anyone have a better name handy ?
To begin with , SQL is not going anywhere . There are some use cases – like the complex transactions in an ERP system – where SQL is an excellent fit . So the idea of NoSQL is more of “not JUST SQL”. The term is like the grand daddy of all nuances.
If we think of all possible things that need a database in it , I think about 20% or so might always need SQL . And another 20% will always need one of the solutions loosely classified as NoSQL . The true issue is – what about the rest of the 60% ?
In general – depending on the skills of a project team, these 60% can be done in either SQL or NoSQL with different trade offs . When I joined MongoDB, I rationalized in my mind that vast majority of that middle 60% would lean towards NoSQL . You can take your own percentage of course depending on your world view 🙂
Now within this NoSQL space , there is plenty of variety too . MongoDB for example is what is called a document database – given the JSON/BSON nature of holding the data. You wouldn’t believe how many times I have been asked whether MongoDB is a solution for storing documents like word and PDF files ! Of course MongoDB can store all kinds of files – pictures too – and it is great for content management applications . But that is just one of say 10 categories of use cases this database can do .
And once I explain the JSON document story – the invariable follow up question is “oh what is the big deal there – doesn’t your competitor do it too?” . Yes there are other solutions out there that can use JSON – there are ones built on XML too . However, the nuance that gets missed is that everyone handles it differently . Some just store it as a BLOB associated with a key , unlike how MongoDB handles it .
So clearly – the “document database” term is not exactly helpful either . A combination of just plain misunderstanding , and some marketing misadventures have made sure that neither NoSQL nor document databases clarify exactly how these various databases differ .
The JSON discussion with anyone who has written a SQL query once in their life usually results in the gotcha moment “oh – so you can’t do Joins in your cool new technology . You do know we can’t live without it right?”. It’s a simple yes or no question in the mind of the person – and they know the right answer . I am now researching history now to find what Henry Ford must have answered to people who asked him ” so what kind of horse whip goes with this car thingy that you are selling?” 🙂
Then I have attempted to explain MongoDB using the Gartner 3V model – which a lot of people already relate to due to the big data hype . So I say things along the lines of “Variety” is the key V that differentiates MongoDB . That doesn’t always cut it – I am tempted to use another V – for “Versalitily”, to point out the differentiating features . But here as a matter of principle – and out of respect for Doug Laney and Gartner – I won’t hijack the original 3V model . Just like I don’t like the original 4Ps of marketing mix being changed . Those models are all fine – we just need to resist the urge to change them for our random interests .
By the way – Is Hadoop considered NoSQL ? Yes ? No? Yes?
I don’t know really. It’s a personal taste thing I guess . There are plenty of initiatives in and around Hadoop to make it more SQL friendly . I can’t really say where one could draw a line .
There are plenty of people who have asked me if MongoDB is another NoSQL system like Hadoop . It always makes me stop in my tracks . How exactly should I answer that ?
To begin with – I don’t know whether Hadoop should be in NoSQL category . Then there is the fact that MongoDB has complimentary features to Hadoop – and is not competitive to Hadoop (despite having some similarities like MapReduce and an aggregation framework). So I can say yes or no and make it sound credible – or I can smile, or I can roll my eyes , or do a combination of all of these things . I also tend to remember the joke about a lawyer asking an accused “Do you still beat your wife every night?” . Yes ? No? Yes?
It’s no big deal really – but if anyone has any bright ideas on a new name to replace NoSQL , please share . You will have my eternal gratitude and I will buy you a pitcher of beer when we meet . Please , please . Pretty please ?